Wagners Award Winning Ribs and our delicious menu items are sure to cure even the biggest of appetities !
  • Buffalo Chicken Wings................................................................5 6.25 12 8.90
    Tossed in one of our Homemade sauces served with Celery & Ranch Dressing. Sauces: Wagner's BBQ, Hot BBQ, Buffalo Hot, Buffalo Mild or try out NEW Chipolte BBQ or Asian Buffalo Sauce
  • Haystack Onions.........................................................................................7.95
    Cliced Thin & Cooked Golden Brown Served with Haystack Sauce
  • Original Taco Dip........................................................................................8.25
    Our original recipe is back! Mixture of Cheese, Jalapenos & Chili topped with Sour Cream served with homemade chips
  • Steak & Mushroom Tidbits........................................................................8.95
    Tender Filet Tidbits Broiled with Mushrooms & Blue Cheese Butter Served with Toasted Costinis
  • Fried Button Mushrooms............................................................................6.95
    Little Buttons of Goodness Served with BBQ Sauce
  • Maryland Crab Cakes.................................................................................9.25
    Our homemade crab cakes can't be beat! Delicious crab in every bite. Served with our Southwest Sauce.
  • Trio Platter....................................................................................................9.95
    Can't Decide... DON'T. Haystack Onions, Fried Mushrooms & Chicken Tenders Served with Southwest Sauce & Wagner's BBQ Sauce.

  • French Onion Soup......................................................................................5.50
  • Chef's Daily Creation.........................................................Cup 2.95 Bowl 4.25

  • Caesar Salad......................................Regular 7.95 + Steak 10.95 + Chicken 8.95
  • Buffalo Chicken Salad.................................................................................9.25
    Breaded Chicken Strips Dipped in Wagner's Spicy BBQ Sauce with Tomato, Celery, Red Onion, Cheddar & Jack Cheese.
  • Iceberg Wedge............................................................Regular 8.95 + Steak 9.95
    Bacon, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion & Wagner's Blue Cheese Dressing
  • House Salad..................................................................................................3.75
    Mixed Greens with Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onions & Croutons

  • Hamburger....................................................................................................7.99
    Guaranteed to make you say Yummmm
  • Cheese Burger..............................................................................................8.50
    Tender & Juicy with American Cheese
  • Bacon & Cheddar Burger.............................................................................8.99
    2 Slices of Thick, Crispy Bacon & Melted Aged Cheddar Cheese
  • Swiss & Shroom Burger................................................................................8.99
    Melted Swiss Cheese & Sauteed Mushrooms
  • Blackened Burger.........................................................................................8.99
    Cajun Spiced Burger with Haystack Onions & Southwest Sauce on a Toasted Onion Roll
  • IU Burger......................................................................................................8.99
    Wagner's BBQ Sauce, Grilled Onions & Ranch Served on a Grilled Onion Roll
  • VU Burger.....................................................................................................10.99
    Two 5 oz. Patties on a Toasted French Roll with Hot BBQ Sauce, Bacon, American & Swiss Cheese, Grilled Onions, SW Sauce & Redskins
  • Purdue Burger...............................................................................................8.99
    Creamy Peanut Butter & Raw Onions on our Famous Pretzel Roll. Strangely Good!!
  • 3-Cheese Burger...........................................................................................9.25
    Melted American, Swiss & Mozzarella Cheese with Grilled Onions on a Toasted Pretzel Roll
  • Blue Cheese Burger.....................................................................................8.99
    Topped with Aged Wisconsin The Best Blue Cheese...Unforgettable
  • Western Burger............................................................................................8.99
    Wagner's BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon & Grilled Onions on a Toasted Onion Roll
  • St Marys Substitute
    Grilled Chicken in any of our burger combinations at no extra charge!!
  • Chicago Beef Sandwich............................................Regular 8.99 + Cheese 2.00
    A Traditional Chicago-Style Classic Served on an 8 inch Italian Loaf. (Peperoncinis & Green Peppers Upon Request) Add Mozzarella Cheese for additional charge.
  • Rib-Eye Steak
    Black Angus 10 oz. Rib-Eye Cooked to Temp Served Open-Face on Grilled Texas Toast. Tender & Juicy!
  • Crab Cake Po Boy........................................................................................10.99
    Two Homemade Crab Cakes on a Pretzel Roll with Lettuce, Tomato & Southwest Sauce
  • Fish Sandwich................................................................................................7.99
    Crisp-Fried Pollock on a Toasted French Roll with Lettuce, Tomato & Tartar Sauce
  • Grilled Chicken Club....................................................................................8.99
    Classic with Lettuce, Tomato, Crispy Bacon, BBQ Ranch & Cheddar Cheese. Served on a Grilled Pretzel Roll
  • Crispy Chicken.............................................................................................9.50
    Served on our Amazing Pretzel Roll with Lettuce, Tomato, Ranch & American Cheese. A Wagner's Favorite!!
  • Buffalo Chicken............................................................................................9.95
    Same as above but we dip our Crispy Chicken in our Mild Buffalo Sauce. CAUTION... It's Addicting!
  • Chicken Tenders...........................................................................................7.95
    Crispy All White Chicken Strips Served with your choice of BBQ Sauce or Ranch
  • Wagner's Fish & Chips.................................................................................8.95
    1/2 Pound of our Crispy Alaskan Pollock Served with Lemon & Tartar Sauce

  • SIDES Served with your choice of two sides: Soup, Salad, Waffle Fries, Coleslaw, Baked Potato, BBQ Baked Beans, Cornbreak Cakes, Seasonal Veggies, Redskins, Mashed/Gravy................... Haystacks 1.50 Soup 2.95 Macaroni 2.95 Potato 2.95
    The prices outlined above will be an additional charge for Haystacks, French Onion Soup, Four Cheese Macaroni, or Double Baked Potato.
  • Black Angus Ribeye Steaks..........................14 oz. Cut 18.99 10 oz. Cut 14.99
  • Black Angus Filet Mignon...............................12 oz. Cut 25.99 8 oz. Cut 22.99
  • 24 oz. Sirloin Steak
    Can you say WOW! Topped with Haystack Onions
    For Extra Flavor.......BlueCheese 3.00 Butter 2.25 Onions 2.50 Mushrooms 3.25
    The prices above outline the additional toppings that are availabe for any of our steaks. These toppings include Blue Cheese Topping, Garlic Butter, Caramelized Onions or Crimini Mushrooms Sauteed in a Wine Sauce.
  • Dave's Homemade Meatloaf......................................................................10.99
    Stacked with Mashed Potatoes, Mushroom Gravy, Haystack Onions. Served with Seasonal Vegetables.
  • Steak Kabobs.............................................................................................11.99
    Tender Pieces of Sirloin Steak, Onions, Peppers & Mushrooms. Served with Choice of Two Sides
  • Crab Stuffed Shrimp...................................................................................15.99
    Five Jumbo Shrimp, Stuffed with Monterey Jack Cheese & Crabmeat
  • Alaskan Pollock Dinner..............................................................................13.99
    This is a Must Try! Lightly Breaded & Golden Fried, Served with Tarter Sauce
  • Sauteed Grouper.........................................................................................14.99
    Florida Grouper Lightly Seasoned & Served with Brown Butter
  • Jumbo Gulf Shrimp.....................................................................................15.99
    Starts with 8 Tender Shrimp Dusted in Our Perfectly Seasoned Breading
  • Grilled Shrimp.............................................................................................15.99
    8 Tender Jumbo Shrimp Marinated with our Traditional New Orleans Seasoning, Grilled Over an Open Flame
  • Seafood Platter...........................................................................................17.99
    Three Crab Stuffed Shrimp, Crab Cakes & 1/2 Pound of Pollock

  • Grilled to Perfection with choice of BBQ Sauce
    Wagner's Original BBQ • Wagner's Spicy • Wagner's Hot
  • Baby Back Ribs....................................................Full Slab 21.99 1/2 Slab 15.99
    Most Award Winning Ribs in the State! Grilled to Perfection in your favorite sauce. Served with your choice of two sides. Also Served: Time Style: Charred & Topped with Extra Sauce.
  • Texas Style
    Smoked & Seasoned! Served with our Famous BBQ Sauce on the Side
  • Half-Roasted BBQ Chicken......................................................................13.99
    Glazed with Our Famous BBQ Sauce or Herb Marinated & Roasted Served with Choice of Two Sides
  • BBQ Grilled Chicken Breast...................................1 Piece 12.99 2 Piece 14.99
    Free Range Boneless Chicken Breast Glazed with our Award Winning Sauce. One Piece Meal served with choice of Two Sides. Two Piece Meal Available
  • Roasted BBQ Pork Platter.........................................................................13.99
    Medallions of slow roasted pork drizzled with BBQ Sauce. Topped with Carmalized Onions. Served with Redskin Potatoes, Coleslaw & Cornbread
  • World Famous BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich.................................................8.99
    A Must Try!! Served on an onion roll with waffle fries
  • Slow Roasted BBQ Pork Sandwich..............................................................8.99
    Slices of slow roasted pork drizzled with BBQ Sauce. Served on grilled, thick cut Vienna Bread with Raw Onions and Waffle Fries
  • BBQ Chicken Sandwich................................................................................8.99
    Chicken Breast Filled in BBQ Sauce & Topped with Lettuce & Tomato. Served on an Onion Roll & Waffle Fries

  • Meat Lovers Combo...................................................................................21.95
    The Best Combo Around! 1/2 Slab of Wagner's Ribs & 10 oz. Filled Ribeye
  • King Combo.................................................................................................26.99
    Another Good Combo Selection! 1/2 Slab of Wagner's Ribs & 6 oz. Grilled Filet
  • Can't Decide? Then Don't! Create a Combo!...........................................18.95
    Choose one from the right and left:
    • 1/2 Slab Wagner's Ribs
    • 10 oz. Black Angus Ribeye
    • 4 Grilled Jumbo Shrimp
    • 4 Fried Jumbo Shrimp
    • 3 Stuffed Shrimp
    • 1/2 lb. Pollock Grilled Chicken Breast
    • 1/2 Roasted Chicken
    • 2 Maryland Crab Cakes

  • Served with Choice of Two Sides
    Soup, Salad, Waffle Fries, Coleslaw, Baked Potato, BBQ Baked Beans, Cornbread Cakes, Seasonal Veggies, Redskins, Mashed/Gravy
  • For Additional Charge: ... Haystacks 1.50 Soup 2.95 Macaroni 2.95 Potato 2.95
    Haystacks, French Onion Soup, Four Cheese Macaroni or Double Baked Potato

  • Pop...............................................................................................................2.89
    Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Pink Lemonade & Dr Pepper - Free Refills
  • Coffee............................................................................................................2.50
  • Hot Tea.........................................................................................................2.50
  • Milk...............................................................................................................2.89